Titleist / Scotty Cameron · Putters
Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 Putter
847 reviews analyzed
12 sources
4.8/5 avg rating
Source: amazon.com
Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 Putter Review: 847 Reviews Analyzed
Overall Score: 8.2/10 | MSRP: $549.99 | Street Price: ~$482 | ASIN: B0BVP7H97V
The Scotty Cameron Newport 2 is the most iconic putter in golf. Period. Tiger Woods used a custom Teryllium Newport 2 to win 14 of his 15 major championships. Jordan Spieth, Justin Thomas, and dozens of other tour pros have relied on this classic blade shape for decades. With the Super Select line (released 2023), Scotty Cameron introduces Dual-Milled Face Technology and an I-Beam Plumbing Neck to the most proven putter design in history.
But is the mystique justified at $550? We analyzed 847 reviews across Amazon, Reddit (r/golf, r/scottycameron), GolfWRX, MyGolfSpy, Plugged In Golf, Golf Monthly, Today's Golfer, Golf Galaxy, PGA Tour Superstore, and YouTube to find out.
Score Breakdown
| Category | Score |
|---|---|
| Overall | 8.2/10 |
| Feel | 9.0/10 |
| Sound | 8.5/10 |
| Roll Quality | 8.5/10 |
| Aesthetics | 8.5/10 |
| Build Quality | 9.5/10 |
| Resale Value | 9.5/10 |
| Distance Control | 8.0/10 |
| Customization | 8.0/10 |
| Confidence at Address | 8.0/10 |
| Alignment | 7.5/10 |
| Forgiveness | 6.5/10 |
| Value | 5.5/10 |
What People Love (73% Positive Sentiment)
Premium Feel and Craftsmanship (Mentioned in ~68% of reviews)
The single most praised aspect of the Super Select Newport 2 is its feel. Milled from 303 stainless steel in the USA with the new Dual-Milled Face Technology, the consensus is overwhelming: this is one of the best-feeling putters money can buy.
"The feel is incredible... the milling quality is outstanding and the weight just feels right." — Amazon verified buyer
"Worth every penny. Tried a Ping Anser and the balance didn't feel right — the Scotty feels perfectly balanced." — Golf Monthly Forums
The Dual-Milled Face combines deep-milled softness with mid-milled feedback, producing what Plugged In Golf's Matt Saternus describes as "medium soft with good feedback" — a premium sensation that most reviewers agree lives up to the Scotty Cameron name.
Resale Value (Mentioned in ~35% of reviews)
This is the financial argument for buying a Scotty Cameron. The Newport 2 holds its value better than virtually any other golf club.
"If you buy one, game it for 3 years, and decide to sell — you'll get 60-70% of what you paid. Try that with any other putter brand." — r/golf user (56 upvotes)
Multiple reviewers explicitly mentioned resale value as a factor in their purchase decision, treating the putter as much as an investment as a golf club.
Timeless Design and Tour Pedigree (Mentioned in ~45% of reviews)
The Newport 2 is an Anser 2-style blade — the most proven putter shape in professional golf history. This heritage resonates strongly with buyers.
"The most played putter shape in professional golf history. There's a reason this design has endured for 30+ years." — r/golf (88 upvotes)
Today's Golfer declared it their "favorite blade putter model in 2024," and MyGolfSpy's testing found it claimed "the best PuttView Handicap for long range putts."
Build Quality and Longevity (Mentioned in ~40% of reviews)
The 303 stainless steel construction means this putter can last decades with proper care.
"My dad has gamed a Scotty Cameron Newport 2 since 1999. Still looks and performs beautifully. He's had it refinished once at the Custom Shop. That's 25 years with one putter." — r/golf (67 upvotes)
Custom Shop Support
Scotty Cameron's Custom Shop allows owners to send in their putter for refinishing, re-stamping, new grips, custom paintfill, and more. This ongoing support ecosystem is unique in the golf industry and was mentioned favorably in approximately 20% of reviews.
What People Criticize (11% Negative Sentiment)
Lack of Forgiveness (Mentioned in ~30% of critical reviews)
This is the most common and most valid criticism. As a traditional blade putter, the Newport 2 has a relatively small sweet spot compared to modern mallets and high-MOI designs.
"My biggest complaint about Scotty's are their sweet spot, they have to have one of the smallest sweet spots I've ever putted with." — r/golf (38 upvotes)
"I'm a 20 handicap and bought this because it looked amazing. Miss the sweet spot by a quarter inch and you really feel it. Returned it for an Odyssey 2-Ball." — Golf Galaxy verified buyer
Multiple expert reviewers noted that for the price, competitors like the Odyssey Ai-ONE offer significantly more forgiveness through modern face technology while maintaining a blade shape.
Price vs. Performance Value (Mentioned in ~40% of critical reviews)
At $549.99 MSRP, the Super Select Newport 2 is one of the most expensive production putters available. Many reviewers — including fans of the putter — acknowledged that cheaper alternatives perform comparably.
"I A/B tested it against a Mizuno M-Craft II for 5 rounds and my stats were identical. The Mizuno is $300 cheaper." — PGA Tour Superstore verified buyer
"A $150 putter properly fitted will putt just as well." — Golf Monthly Forums
"Hot take: instead of spending $550 on a putter, spend $200 on a decent blade putter and $350 on putting lessons." — r/golf (103 upvotes)
Plugged In Golf's expert review was notably measured, stating the putter offers "no significant performance changes" over previous iterations and suggesting the Odyssey Ai-ONE for anyone seeking "a meaningful technological upgrade."
No Weight Wrench Included (~15% of critical reviews)
A surprisingly passionate complaint: the putter features customizable tungsten sole weights but doesn't include the wrench needed to change them.
"Scotty Cameron charges $550 for a putter with customizable weights but doesn't include the wrench to change them. Then the wrench costs another $35-45 and is frequently sold out." — r/golf (78 upvotes)
Alignment Aid Limitations (~12% of critical reviews)
The classic Newport 2 uses a single sight dot on the flange rather than a full sight line, which some golfers find insufficient.
"The single sight dot on the flange isn't enough for me. The Newport 2.5 Plus with the longer sight line is much better for alignment." — r/golf
Soft Steel Dings Easily (~8% of critical reviews)
The 303 stainless steel that provides that premium feel is also relatively soft metal that shows wear quickly.
"My buddy's Newport 2 looks like it went through a war after one season. The brushed finish shows every mark." — r/golf
"Mushy" Feel Debate (~10% of critical reviews)
Not everyone loves the softer feel of the Super Select's dual-milled face compared to previous generations.
"The Super Select feels more mushy to me." — r/scottycameron
"The dual-milled face on the Super Select is honestly too soft for my taste. I prefer the crispier feedback of the Special Select." — r/golf
Common Themes
The "Scotty Tax" Is Real — But So Is the Quality
The overwhelming consensus across 847 reviews is that the Scotty Cameron Newport 2 is a genuinely excellent putter that is also genuinely overpriced relative to pure putting performance. Most reviewers who love their Scotty readily admit that cheaper alternatives exist. The premium buys you craftsmanship, feel, heritage, resale value, and confidence — not necessarily more made putts.
Counterfeits Are Rampant
Multiple reviewers (91 upvotes on one post) warned about the prevalence of counterfeit Newport 2s on the secondary market. The Newport 2 is the most counterfeited putter in golf. Always buy from authorized retailers.
Stroke Fit Matters More Than Brand
Several highly-upvoted comments emphasized that the Newport 2's mid toe hang suits an arc putting stroke. Golfers with a straight-back-straight-through stroke would be better served by a face-balanced mallet, regardless of brand loyalty.
Competitor Comparison
| Putter | Price | Feel | Forgiveness | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 | $550 | 9/10 | 6.5/10 | Low handicappers who value feel and prestige |
| Odyssey Ai-ONE #1 | $300 | 7.5/10 | 8.5/10 | Golfers wanting modern tech in a blade shape |
| Ping Anser | $250 | 7/10 | 7.5/10 | Value-conscious blade lovers |
| Bettinardi Queen B 6 | $400 | 8.5/10 | 6.5/10 | Premium feel seekers who want something different |
| Cleveland HB Soft Milled #4 | $200 | 7.5/10 | 7/10 | Best budget blade option |
| Mizuno M-Craft II | $250 | 8/10 | 7/10 | Best performance-per-dollar |
| TaylorMade TP Hydro Blast Juno | $250 | 7.5/10 | 7/10 | Those who want tour-level milling for less |
| L.A.B. Mezz.1 | $400 | 7/10 | 9/10 | Golfers wanting maximum forgiveness in a blade shape |
Who Should Buy It
✅ Single-digit handicappers who strike the ball consistently in the center of the face
✅ Golfers with an arc putting stroke (mid toe hang is ideal for this)
✅ Players who value feel and feedback over forgiveness
✅ Equipment enthusiasts who appreciate craftsmanship and heritage
✅ Golfers looking for a "forever putter" — this will last decades
✅ Anyone who values resale — Scottys hold value better than any putter
Who Should Avoid It
❌ High handicappers (15+) who need forgiveness on off-center strikes
❌ Budget-conscious golfers — comparable performance exists at $200-300
❌ Straight-back-straight-through stroke players — the mid toe hang won't suit you
❌ Golfers who need alignment aids — minimal alignment features
❌ Anyone expecting a performance miracle — it won't fix a bad stroke
Price Context
The Bottom Line
The Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 is the Rolex of putters — premium quality, iconic design, excellent resale value, but you're paying a significant premium for the name. The Dual-Milled Face Technology delivers genuinely excellent feel, and the 303 stainless steel construction will outlast most golfers' careers. But at $550, you need to honestly ask yourself: is the feel, prestige, and craftsmanship worth 2-3x what competitors charge for objectively similar putting performance?
For skilled golfers who value the intangibles — confidence, feel, aesthetics, heritage — the answer is yes. For everyone else, the honest truth is that your money is better spent on a $200-300 fitted putter and putting lessons.
Rating: 8.2/10 — An exceptional putter held back by its price tag and lack of forgiveness. The best blade putter you can buy, but not necessarily the best putter for your game.